I guess I shall share my input.
From the moment I came back about a week and a half ago, I was highly confused over what this crafting plugin was and how to work it. Though, with a little help from OOC, I was able to grab the basics of it pretty quickly. Though, so far I have not been using it and just wandering around. The most time I had touching it was when I was playing an Orc 2 days or so ago. That was when I got deep into it. So far, I have mixed feelings, I will separate them both for easy reading pleasure:
The Good:
What I liked about the plugin was that it was really, and I mean REALLY immersive, albeit some of the wait times. It made me feel like, with some items, I was actually crafting the items in an actual roleplay environment. It also had it's own custom names for items, such as the dough, pancakes, hooks, hammers, etc. That, I really liked. I also liked how the skills and crafting were formed together, that was really nice.
The Bad:
Though, I feel some of the ways this plugin runs is a bit... off putting. As I said before, the wait times are sometimes strange. Sometimes it bugged, and sometimes it didnt on some things, that I am sure has been revealed from feedback. There was also the situation with the UI for me when waiting for items to be crafted. Before, I did not know how to navigate the UI to craft items that had a waiting period. It took me a good day or so to realize I had to actually refresh the UI to see the icon to claim my item. I am pretty sure I was not the first to be confused on how that worked, so yeah. Also, when waiting to craft, and during server restarts, since I was unlucky at one time, I ended up losing the items used to craft. Though, I do not know if that was the server's fault or not, I would just like to add that in. I do not know if this is in the crafting as well, but the expiration dates on crafted food is also somewhat of a weird thing. It still goes while people are offline, and people lose a great deal of product and food because of this. I know it has been addressed before, but I believe maybe a 3 day expiration time. Also, the long strings of crafting materials to make other things is good at some points, but sometimes it just seems like a hassle. That is just my own experience with it due to low resources, but that was just my thoughts on that.
The Verdict:
All in all, this plugin has great potential when cleaned up of the obvious bugs. Though tedious at times, it is really good RP for those armor, swordsmen, and cooks and what not to RP with. It is really one of the best crafting mods I have had the pleasure to come into contact with, even though I havent really been in contact with any before this server I believe.
This is my feedback, feel free to say your do's, or don't, I do not mind since I am sure all of this was brought up at one point or another.