Borin

Some level of reference to server events or IRP society would be appreciated, yet I agree there is a balance between standards and gatekeeping.

All memes aside, I don't think the accusations of gate-keeping are entirely fair, it's not difficult to write out an application  and I can't see any evidence that lowering standards has helped player retention (I'd argue it's counter-productive). We're not Fantasy RP, we should quite reasonably be advocating for quality over quantity in our new players, not that we're demanding experienced rpers just those that can demonstrate a decent grasp of the lore. Not demanding that new player write a proper essay, but that wasn't what Borin was saying either. 

You already were a seasoned minecraft roleplayer before applying to lord of the craft though. Perhaps it would have been different if EmpireWar RP hadn't been around :)