Love the poetry bro, unique way to voice an opinion. I for one think you've got some talent. Kind of weird it's being used here, but by all means don't stop now.
On the topic though, since it seems mentioned here as Roleplay combat versus PvP, they each have their functions. While PvP is obnoxious, it too holds purpose and while many dislike it, just as many like it for it's uses.
PvP:
+Ends combat quickly.
+Easier to involve multiple people.
+Gives everyone an 'even' chance to start with.
- "You only won because of your orc buff!"
- People who train PvP so they can be the best warrior.
- Farmers killing you because they are l33t swordsman.
RP:
+ More dynamic combat.
+ Better expression of both the character and the actions.
+ Allows for both players to debate how actions should be, along with give some spice to it.
- Takes forever.
- Allows Power-gaming.
- The amount of martial arts ninjas running around.
While we all have our preferences, both have reasons to enjoy them, and by respecting those reasons we can come together as a community rather than have these debates over PvP or RP default. Defender's Default makes it possible to experience both, and enjoy a good time on the server. While it may not be too fun for you, the guy who wants to do Magic or the warrior who needs a quick PvP may want to have their fun too. Sometimes it's best to bite the bullet, and let the community have a good time.