Reading through the application form again (I only remember the very first one, and we all know no one gave a diddly-**** about how well it was written) I noticed that it's pretty much mandatory to tell everyone how you're going to play and what should they expect. Honestly, If I know that this guy is a rich bastard, or that elf is some posh High Elf trash collector, I just can't make myself be interested in roleplaying with them. The idea of RP to me is learning more about the characters themselves, but as of now, I only need to check out the applications they wrote. Yea, sure, you can call it Metagaming, but no matter how hard you keep all that info down in your throat, it's still going to come out sooner or later with a gag reflex.
Open Response Questions also gave me a slight burst on the buttons. Why the hell is the dialogue mandatory? What if the guy is applying as a mute? Explaining sign language ain't no easy task, and I still get horribly dizzy when I try to imagine that happening.
Biography. Yea, I have a problem with that too. I wouldn't be Hwaldar if I wouldn't have a problem with something. It is expected from new people to apply as characters which exsisted within the LotC world. Okay, I guess, but I have my doubts about that. What if the character was born in a human town, which was (most surprisingly) called St.Petersburg. Would that count as screwing up? Maybe there was some Saint Peter in LotC world, but everyone either forgot to write a book or something about him, or were just roaring drunk? Letting some extra imagination in wouldn't hurt too much. It could probably give a feeling that there's more to our surroundings than what is already known and documented.
Oh wait, I almost forgot. The definitions of RP, meta and powergaming. Oh yes.
This one's a rather small complaint, but is it really necessary to go crazy on that one? If the guy gets the right idea about it, then it shouldn't be something to pick on about. Some people seem to have the idea about those things right, but still get told that it's "not detailed enough". It hobbles my bobbles.
ONE MORE THING!
Just a question, really. Is it mandatory that all who apply as Orcs must have them dumb as rocks? I'd love to see more Gothic 3 style Orcs, you know, the more intelligent type? The type that can SPEAK HUMAN LANGUAGE? Would be a nice change from the casual ooga boogars.
I hope I wasn't too rude this time around, but I believe it was for the best that I say what I did.
Other than that, I checked the application forms, and they seem smaller, when comparing sizes. That's a good thing. Compact and sleek apps make everyone's lives better.
Throwing rocks at bandits is villainous. read that a few times and tell me if it sounds "realistic".
Realism in a fantasy game, some people should drink less.