Ah, I remember now! Just a little piece of information which I believe would be valuable to this discussion. I am sure Shiftnative remembers this as well, as I think it was he who was the one who had spoken it.
Lord of the Craft was originally designed to be a roleplaying server, not an RPG server. The difference is, one revolves around quests, NPC's and player to environment interaction. The other is strictly player to player interaction, and the stories involved therewith.
It was, at one point, envisioned that Lord of the Craft Roleplaying server was to be the initial stepping stone into a vaster roleplaying community. That, from this, Lord of the Craft would exapand into a vast Roleplaying hub, not only encompassing minecraft as the largest roleplaying server there was, but indeed extending its reaches into the wider internet. Spanning games and forums and the Lord of the Craft logo being that which represents more than just Minecraft Roleplay, but a giant community of roleplayers of all sorts of games.
Perhaps Shift, you yourself remember this? It was, at one stage, the plan after all.
Alas, times do change. Perhaps it is not the past you should be using to justify your position, but rather what the playerbase has become now. For there is without a doubt a shift in the wants of the playerbase, for better or for worse. It does seem to me that the vast majority of those who speak their opinion on these forums wish for a more laid back, less roleplay intensive experience. Who am I to argue with the majority?