I am not against my experience being affected by other players, please do not put words in my mouth. I am against a return to the period of PVP dominance of Anthos/Fringe/Thales/Athera/Vailor where the RP was as low effort as could be. Where your only value to a nation was in how good your PC was for clickyclickylookmomimwinning. I interact with people outside of my clique quite a bit, and even go into the opposing side to understand why they RP the way they do. My problem is with people whose idea of a good time is running in and ruining mine with a random raid, stealing what i have on me that may have taken months to obtain, in 5 minutes or less. Now you want them to be able to rip open the chests I've purposefully left my valuables in to steal and sell on the auction for vastly inflated sums of petty cash?
You talk of concessions, but you're not making any that matter. You're giving all power to the folks who are here specifically for the pvp combat once again.
Belated edit: The "Raids make RP" argument doesn't hold water considering they kill everyone to begin with. The losing side has everything effectively voided, plus a loss of what they had on their personage with no explanation. Nice.