LotC has always had Pvp ever since it has began. There is no sense of trying to get rid of it completely, because it will never happen. Just 'cause we call it a RP server doesn't mean it doesn't have other aspects to it.
And if you say that it doesn't make RP sense, that it is just about who is a better minecraft pvper or not, think of it this way. If you pvp as a character a good deal on the server, you should be getting better at the actual minecraft mechanics. If you don't pvp that much on the server, and you create a character that's a master swordsmen, then obviously your gonna suck at pvp.
Sorry for the rant, but I've seen soooooo many of these anti-pvp things and they are just so annoying.