thaddeus11

Not necessarily true. Groups typically agree on styles. Times where there was a 2 v 2 or a 1 v 1 could require a roll. Some 3 v 1s as well but That'd be rare probably. That leaves 1 v 2s 3 v 1s and in a rare case 2 v 2s.  The roll isn't bad either because it leaves one party satisfied randomly rather than it being forced by a server rule. RP defaulters have a chance to RP pvp defaulters have a chance to pvp.

Yeah but why is randomly deciding which party is satisfied better than having it be consistent?

Yeah because then both PvPers and RPers have a chance to do the style they enjoy.