The Assault Of Dawn

[Dawn 55]

((We are PG? We are not saying you MUST perma kill your char. We are just saying that you should have to the monks. I also think we are not just PG, alot of people do not just villains. This is prejudice. ))

((The powergaming came in when he emoted slashing her neck with no chance for her to escape or respond to the action. This is not prejudice, it is fact.))

[Lynx 158]

((The powergaming came in when he emoted slashing her neck with no chance for her to escape or respond to the action. This is not prejudice, it is fact.))

((He had you as a hostage, there would be no way around it. We told the people to back off and they still tried to walk closer to you. It would not be powergaming due to the fact he had you help from behind. If anything you were powergaming, I had several people tell us that after he put you down you were talking. Not to mention the fact that you were performing surgery in medieval times.__

[empirerebel 305]

((The powergaming came in when he emoted slashing her neck with no chance for her to escape or respond to the action. This is not prejudice, it is fact.))

((What kind of surgery was performed on you? ))

[Dawn 55]

((He had you as a hostage, there would be no way around it. We told the people to back off and they still tried to walk closer to you. It would not be powergaming due to the fact he had you help from behind. If anything you were powergaming, I had several people tell us that after he put you down you were talking. Not to mention the fact that you were performing surgery in medieval times.__

((He walked into a crowd of armed guards, magically got a hold of Dawn while holding all others back and dodging any attack that came his way, never losing his grip on his sword or his balance. After a long arugument in OOC over how this is even possible, I said to the guards to let him take me since he was disrupting so much rp time. He then drug Dawn outside of the gates and slit her neck...Where is the confusion over the powergaming issue here?))

[Dawn 55]

((What kind of surgery was performed on you? ))

((I have no idea, I was primarily afk during this role play aruging with susitsu in /tells. I saw enough to know they used potions and dressed the wound. I am sure it was nothing more miraculous than the "kidnapping" itself.))

[Lynx 158]

((He walked into a crowd of armed guards, magically got a hold of Dawn while holding all others back and dodging any attack that came his way, never losing his grip on his sword or his balance. After a long arugument in OOC over how this is even possible, I said to the guards to let him take me since he was disrupting so much rp time. He then drug Dawn outside of the gates and slit her neck...Where is the confusion over the powergaming issue here?))

((First of all, There was no guards behind you, only beside. He walked up behind you and put a sword to your throat. He did not dodge others attacks due to the fact that I was behind him and that is where they were attacking. No one tried to shoot him or attack from the side or front. Since we were being surrounded we moved you outside. I was behind him and burk protected his side. Once we got outside the guards still followed. We told them to stop and they didnt. So he slit your throat. Also you made no attempt to get free which you could have. We are not saying you have to kill off your char just that it is a bit powergaming that you didnt go to the monks. We had many people outside the house saying the things they did to heal you were unrealistic and a bit powergaming. Also if you told your guards not to do anything oocly isnt that metagaming? If you went to the monks you would have been fine. This way it hit many vital organs and your vocal cords. Since you never went to the monks there is no way you should be able to talk))

[Dawn 55]

((First of all, There was no guards behind you, only beside. He walked up behind you and put a sword to your throat. He did not dodge others attacks due to the fact that I was behind him and that is where they were attacking. No one tried to shoot him or attack from the side or front. Since we were being surrounded we moved you outside. I was behind him and burk protected his side. Once we got outside the guards still followed. We told them to stop and they didnt. So he slit your throat. Also you made no attempt to get free which you could have. We are not saying you have to kill off your char just that it is a bit powergaming that you didnt go to the monks. We had many people outside the house saying the things they did to heal you were unrealistic and a bit powergaming. Also if you told your guards not to do anything oocly isnt that metagaming? If you went to the monks you would have been fine. This way it hit many vital organs and your vocal cords. Since you never went to the monks there is no way you should be able to talk))

((Many others who were there can tell you what they saw as well, and it does not fit your description. I will not bother to banter with you back and forth on who is right and who is wrong.

I do ask this though...What about being a sword swinging villian gives you correct credentials ICly to be a medical expert, have the ability to judge someone else's healing skills versus a monk, or diagnose the exact injury delivered before the victum hits the ground? You accuse me of powergaming, but in reality you are unhappy that I did not follow your idea of how the story should go. I have impeded on no one else's rights to respond to the role play,nor I have provented anyone else's story from unfolding...But I am not responsible for ensuring that my character follow your script.))

[Nononymous 306]

((All of you stop arguing, what is done is done. No harm was done, nothing was lost, now everyone just stop arguing. I hate to mediate but Dawn, to us villains it may seem a little bit like prejudice towards us, and I admit you have every reason to be prejudice considering all the poor RP that has happend on occasions. At the same time, Lynx, consider this; do you think Dawn OOCly wanted to go along with it? I myself did something similar a week or so back. I had captured a Seventis guard and messaged him OOCly to ask if he was alright with me hanging him outside the Seventis gates. He agreed on the condition he did not die, so we made that the noose was not strong enough and he simply sputerred as he lay on the ground, gasping for air. What I reccomend you do, as I learned this the hard way, is check to see if the other team/person is okay with what you were about to do, no one like's having their character shaped by someone else. Would you enjoy it if someone ran up to you and stabbed you in the throat, forcing you to go to the temple unwillingly so as to avoid PG? I know I would not. Also, I feel bad for Dawn as she is often a target for bandit attacks and such. I mean god, give the lady a break, every ten minutes someone is trying to capture her and stab her, etc. I would know, I once had to carry her a long while to kidnap her involving a golem, peacekeepers, and other bandits. I don't wish to get everyone on me about this, but I am tired of seeing two good RPers fight over something so trivial, something already in the past. With that I leave this post.))

[V0idsoldier 1139]

((Dawn, Zezimus and laterre captured my character once, tying him down, and executing him, and they did not complain when I told them I would not let it be a perma death. A rule is, you cannot force a perma death on someone. This is a world of magic, of elves and dwarves and orcs, not everything has to be realistic guys. Even the most serious of wounds can be healed by a amazing surgeon, or dedicated cleric, get some imagination. There is no need to fight, this caused great rp, and that is what matters. Ivrae, don't want to bash you or anything, but you are frantically defending dawn by flexing your muscles, this is a rp forum, a rp topic, if someone wants to *runs up to gates and shouts* then let them, they don't add anything, but no need to warn them! I hope everyone can see the good in this in the end!))

[Song Druid 1486]

Okay, this has gotten far out of hand.

IF YOU HAVE ISSUE WITH THE WAY THIS RP WENT DOWN OPEN A BAN REPORT AND IT WILL BE HANDLED IN THIS WAY.

Please stop making these posts in which you publicly call out or diminish other people's rp, ability, personality and actions. There obviously is a misunderstanding here that would be better handled via teamspeak or ban report but not in the RP section. This thread is locked and so help me if I see this drug into the status update section I'm giving whichever party involved 2 increases in warning level.

[steelersfan1221 300]

Moved to the Great Library. It shall be sorted into appropriate category shortly.