Unwillingly

Canonism and Xionism aren't inherently shit-tier religions. It's the players who have taken a cursory glance and diminished them both to the most bare bones understanding of them (the aesthetics of christianity and assuming it's just real world scripture, 'killing the gods') and don't bother to look any deeper

many people on the server would benefit from knowing people do not care about how they are perceived nearly as much as they think they do

(and would benefit a lot from becoming more of a genuine individual than a maniac obsessed with minecraft self image) 

Allowing characters to be obviously sneaky is okay. People act like nosy hawks, like let a brother *tiptoed behind the lad towards the alleyway.
People CAN and SHOULD play foolishly or allow their characters to be tricked despite them OOCLY knowing otherwise.

We gotta take small losses like that