This is going to be a really shitty post but. And do mind; this is all stereotyping.
1: People are not putting an effort in their Villain rp.
There used to be this thing where you actually had to work to get Villain rights. It took an effort, was it hard? No, not at all. It simply took an effort and a well thought out character.
The quality of villain rp has been on a steady decline ever since the removal of Villain Applications.
And I honestly am baffled that while everyone sees this. And everyone is noddig their heads "Oh, villain rp so bad." None actually supports the idea of reintroducing the one thing that stopped all of these issues.
You've tried giving everyone the permission to be a villain; it clearly didn't work out.
So why not revert the change and start up: New Villain Applications.
Yes, I know it'd be shitty to write those applications out again. But wait, there's more! (Input cheesy salesline.) The Solution! How to introduce New Villain Applications:
Nobody has to make a Villain Application. Yes, you read that right. No villain applications for anyone! Unless you get: Reported, Banned, Blacklisted, Strike reported, Warned, Lackluster rp, ... (The Staff can set these rules out.)
So what does this means?
Everyone can play as a Villain. Nobody is restricted in their actions. However once you've been reported and found guilty you actually have to make a Villain application.
We are not talking about an Appeal here, we're talking about a legit Villain Application.
I have this hobby of skimming through the bans and appeals, let me tell you. They're '******' zero effort.
So rather than having this 'formality' because that's what it is. The Appeal is simply a formality.
Rather than having this formality, you actually get really punished. Or rather you have to show the staff you're capable of playing as a Villain. You'll have to write a Villain application. What does this means and how will it impact me as a player:
This will have no impact on you if:
You are a regular player.
You are a white knight, guard, ... and act in good nature.
You are a villain and roleplay properly.
This will impact you if:
You are a villain and are horrible at roleplay.
You are a villain and always force PvP.
End.