Cyndikate

I second what Quavinir said

I LOVE EVIL CHARACTERS! When they are done right. Murdering someone for little reason to back it is what bothers me, that and just "Ok, now we PVP (because I really just want to get your stuff, and don't want to RP at all, and this is the fastest way to kill you)"

Subtle evil > obvious evil, unless it's done very well and makes logical sense.

That's exactly how I feel about villain RP right now. The only time villain RP would piss me off is that the villain provides really bad RP and pulls stupid ****. Like sneaking around a house in armor when people are chatting, and one line kills them. I usually tell them that I don't enjoy their RP afterwards.