Venomous_Pup

This will actually be a buff because then it becomes harder to tell who is dookie dog water. Please don't add this.

Can't be bothered to actually make this as a meme, but guy putting stick in his bicycle. Primnya clearly hates himself enough to write amendments and lore for you ungrateful bastards so I think he is punished enough, all to ensure the server has some consistency, while perhaps sometimes misguided, ultimately comes down to the fact that the missing consistency makes it incredibly difficult to determine what is what, because most people fail to remember, this server is ultimately a faction war in which you try to garner enough support from staff and players so you can enforce your head canon onto others. I think the chaotic good option is to let Primnya lose on lore to PP all the lore (Prima Patch). Then staff can review a giant bunch of changes in one go, or better yet, just let him go hog wild unsupervised and if he tries to slide something silly he will be vaporized not only by staff, but by the community as a whole, because it is clear that everyone is willing to jump on Primnya as evidence by this Meme Amendment (A-meme-dment if you will). What is truly baffling, is to not weaponize this individual's passion for the lore so that the server can be better, after all, writing is the task of drafting upon drafting, perhaps you are jealous that you are incapable of devising the most simplest of amendments (In my case, I am in fact, paradoxically busy and lazy), instead mockery is made of Primnya. So I end with I hope Primnya will pugsy you and tells you to cope by writing an amend so you aren't doggy dog water at PvP. May God forgive us for our sins against the Jesus of LotC.

A Witch remembers when her challenges were unanswered by the very same individual, how many years she watched the beast get mercy purely born from apathy by those unwilling to commit time to be wasted against them. No longer it seems. "LET THE ROT BE CULLED OR MAY IT TAKE US WITH IT AS IT SHOULD!"

Adopt the meta my Witch has, where if anyone copies the books I've written and sells them, I'll hunt them down like a dog and disjoin their skull from their body. I think the best defence against it really is to include your name INSIDE the actual book, the biggest issue is even without the book copying mods, there is so many other ways to be able to copy them that unless you get caught doing it or admit to it, it would basically be impossible to detect, which it kinda would be with the mods currently since they all work client side. But unironically, I think it would also be kinda cool to try to tackle it IRPly as well, start hunting down those that do plagiarism and throw rotten tomatos at them or something.

Earplugs don't require any Alchemy FA to make already, as it falls within Botany under Paddfoot, so players are required to destroy it.

What makes the Earplug meta effective is the fact you can simply have them lodged in your ears free, and I do believe as it currently is you can prepare them, while I think gameplay wise, it is cheese, I don't think anyone should argue you can't prepare before combat, because if that is the case, on the extreme end of it, no one should be wearing armour before combat and we all have to spend our start emotes equipping it. I was gonna write something when I had the time, as I think a better solution is to define a Earplug item and Earmuff item, Earplugs requiring an emote to 'activate' them, whereas Earmuffs don't, however, either you can use them with light armored helms or cannot be wearing a helmet, hadn't decided. Feel like there is alot more to consider to making it so they remain useful, but not outright cancel abilities, at least in close quarters. Something else to mention, Earplugs I am pretty sure is something somewhat uncommonly deployed, even if you remove the fact of Azdrazi or Wight abilities, you have an alchemical that emits a piercing sound that disrupts focus and disorient, and following that, as an individual if a loud enough sound does go off and you are a Mage you would lose focus and have to reset casting. This is just simply a result of LotC 'arm races', when you sufficiently deal with enough problems, in the case of Black Church, being raided by Azdrazi plenty and learning their abilities and looking for ways to counter it (or the min maxers who look at every lore piece who scan every ability to work out how to counter it before they even know it exists). People are gonna prepare what they can before they go into battle to ensure they win, doesn't really matter whom.

My only suggestion imo is to make Sea Forging a general 'Water Forging' so people can have a bit more freeformity to it without having to make 'River Forging' or 'Lake Forging' or w/e else.

Definitely a step in the right direction, even with magics that never had OOC Oversight. I know one player tried to skimp on teaching, and it was difficult to get anything done because a lot of it happened between early 2024 through mid 2025, and I only got informed about it in late 2025, which brought up the slew of issues Squak mentioned. Hopefully, in time, it can return in some form, but I think it would be worth mentioning that people need to report these issues as they crop up, as the longer it is left, the more difficult it can be to get it handled, and it ultimately ends up lowering the quality of RP for everyone around. Even if you aren't staff, it's everyone's job to make sure standards are upheld, and ultimately, trying to 'cheat' for Minecraft magic by accepting bad teaching may reflect on you.

I think this red line regarding having one heart functionally accounting for three to make salts undermines the purpose of having the heart in the first place somewhat considering how untaboo it is to butcher people in this world (as someone mentioned), Argentum was meant to be taboo to a degree because you required a living sacrifice and needed to perform a death blood magic ritual to even forge it, yet its in the hands of countless people because you can just sacrifice one random dude. With these salts, it is even more so, considering that if you kill a non-klone Corc, you can get seven Vampire Dust and the heart from them. If there is meant to be weight behind killing other players to secure a means to identify Corcs, I think it is fair to ask that it is one heart for one, however, I think it is fair that the hearts last longer than 2 days, upwards to a week if this change is made.

To stop worst-case insane cheese, would it be worthwhile to include a limit on limb gathering from Vampiric folk that gets turned into dust if they do not get killed, mostly given the fact that you have Tawkin and BM currently, which allows you to functionally regenerate limbs, you could just nugget Corcs, regrow their limbs, repeat. (As funny as that would be to have factories of enslaved Corcs being pulled apart for dust.)

A Kindred far into the present came to witness this vision, through an act she never thought to accomplish, it didn't make sense yet, but it would soon enough..

PLEASE. To put it in perspective, as I talked about in a different Discord, only counting ten Aether players, they are granted 14 edit tokens a week. You can get a full stack of Sugar from CT completely free, as you require no tools. With 14 tokens, you can edit 64 items in a stack, which grants you about 896 salt items per week. Times this by ten for a whopping production of 8960 salt items, which means to run out over the course of the year, you would need to test 24.5 people a day. This is just with ten Aether players, this doesn't consider the fact of other VIP members banding together or voting milestones, granted a bit extreme but uncapped production for an item that can instantly expose a Corc despite how carefully they play to be ruined because they get caught in some gate house is cooked.