credit to slug for the title
Forum banishments, wanted posters, bounty posts, and other law-related roleplay missives are by no means unheard of on our server. For as long as I can remember, various groups and factions have used the forums as a means of RP communication to practically every player on the server, even some of the inactive ones who’ve been on hiatus for who knows how long. The forums have become a staple point for practically all widespread RP gossip, politics, and communication. Of course, there’s nothing terrible about that alone. At least, that’s not the focal point of this forum post. I’d like to talk about something else.
Imagine this: Your character is a criminal, dark mage, dark creature, you name it. You’re in a city, hoping to rob someone of their minas or some sort of RP items. As you’re prowling around, looking for your target, you spot a player by themself in the depths of the city, far away from the main square — no one is around. This is perfect.
You approach the player, managing to corner them. They’re thrown off, but you draw your blade, cast your magic, reveal your claws, transform into something hideous, and then— they scream for help in one emote.
You’ve been through this before, you know the routine. Ten ISA men will be at your heels before you can even finish your emote. So you quickly make haste, fleeing the scene before anyone inevitably MCly arrives.
After you leave, the following dialogue takes place between the participants: Guard 204 approaches the victim. Victim 89 cries out, “I was almost attacked!” Guard 204 asks, “What did he look like?” Victim 89 replies, “Blonde hair, blue eyes, dark clothes.” [LOOC] Player204: what was the person’s MC name? [LOOC] Player89: john_doe It’s a shame, but that’s alright. At least you didn’t get caught. You log off, a few hours pass, you check the forums, and there’s a new wanted poster up. You click on it.
Your most recent entire HD minecraft skin is plastered at the very top, and below it, one line of text entailing: [!] A sketch is drawn of the criminal.
Congratulations, most of the server has full access to the exact appearance of your character down to the pixel without even having to log on, and the people who posted your wanted poster barely had to lift a finger— literally (It’s two clicks to do this).
It’s an age-old problem that, go figure, isn’t moderated, even if the player doesn’t bother to do the bare minimum like adding alterations such as a grayscale filter to the screenshot. However, in my opinion, adding a filter of any kind doesn’t negate the case I’m trying to make. Most of these skins are pulled from NameMC, which already has its own filter tools that allows the skin to be edited in less than five seconds. Even if your method of editing isn’t done through NameMC, anyone with more than a couple of brain cells can figure out how to do it relatively easily. It’s not a solution, so let’s not pretend it is one.
I’m not saying the mods should add another rule— that’s the last thing we need. Instead, I’d like to ask: why does this common process of copy-pasting skins not constitute as metagaming, or even subpar RP, especially for something that usually targets one singular player while simultaneously being available to most LOTC players? How can we as a community, or even staff, advocate for quality RP, but then hardly bat an eye at things like this?
Sure, alright, it would make more sense to be able to do this if LOTC possessed the technology or even lore to instantly capture a picture in-RP, but it doesn’t (sorry Hanrahan). We know that any and all methods of identification must either be done through witnesses, artist rendition, or physical description. Simple screenshots completely overlook a character’s ability to recall details or even match a description. Although being less reliable, they undoubtedly hold more substance, value, potential, and sometimes humor, than any simple screenshot could.
This is by no means impossible, or even detrimental to the continuity of these types of posts. In fact, player @Caelriadoes a great job at showcasing how wanted posters can be made using purely description and imagery. He's made a variety of wanted posters as of late, and not a single one of them had a screenshot of a player's skin.
To the players who go through the effort of actually writing your target’s description as opposed to taking the effortless and easy route, keep up the good work. To the players who would rather post screenshots, do better. It only takes a modicum of creativity and effort to make a bounty post or wanted poster without the usage of NameMC screenshots.
There's loads of arguments, points, and criticisms I could address, but I believe I got the general idea down. I haven't seen this exactly "talked about" before, aside from brief comments during a conversation or maybe status updates.